A.C. Bradley’s Theory of Shakespearean Tragedy

A.C. Bradley, a renowned literary scholar, is best known for his analysis of Shakespeare’s tragedies. His book Shakespearean Tragedy (1904) became a seminal work in Shakespeare studies, offering a detailed examination of four major tragedies: Hamlet, Othello, King Lear, and Macbeth. Bradley’s theory remains influential because of his deep psychological analysis of the characters and the structural framework he identified in Shakespeare’s tragic plays. Here’s a summary of Bradley’s theory on Shakespearean tragedy:

1. The Nature of Tragedy

Bradley defines a Shakespearean tragedy as a play depicting the fall of a noble character from a position of high status to one of suffering and disaster, which evokes pity and fear in the audience. The protagonist is typically a person of great power and influence, whose downfall is both inevitable and brought about by their own actions, despite external circumstances playing a role.

2. The Tragic Hero

According to Bradley, Shakespeare’s tragedies revolve around a tragic hero who possesses certain defining characteristics:

• Noble Stature: The tragic hero is of high rank, often a king, prince, or military leader. Their greatness makes their fall more dramatic and impactful.
• Flaw or Error (Hamartia): The hero is not a perfect person; they possess a tragic flaw, often related to their personality or moral weakness. For example, Hamlet’s indecisiveness, Othello’s jealousy, and Macbeth’s ambition all lead to their downfall.
• Internal Conflict: Bradley highlights that Shakespearean tragic heroes are deeply introspective, struggling with internal conflicts that drive their actions. This inner turmoil makes them more human and relatable to the audience.
• Downfall and Suffering: The tragic hero experiences a reversal of fortune (peripeteia) and a series of events that lead to their destruction. However, their downfall is not only personal but also affects the world around them, often leading to widespread chaos or disaster.

3. The Role of Fate and Circumstance

Bradley acknowledges that while the tragic hero’s own choices contribute to their downfall, external factors also play a significant role. These could be chance events, the actions of others, or societal forces that contribute to the hero’s destruction. For instance, in Romeo and Juliet, fate plays a role through unfortunate coincidences, while in Othello, Iago’s manipulations contribute to Othello’s downfall.

However, Bradley emphasizes that the ultimate responsibility for the tragic hero’s downfall lies with the hero themselves. Their tragic flaw leads them to make crucial decisions that seal their fat

4. The Moral Order

A key aspect of Bradley’s theory is the notion of a moral order in Shakespearean tragedy. According to Bradley, Shakespeare’s tragedies are not merely stories of personal suffering; they also reflect a disruption in the larger cosmic or moral order. The hero’s fall often signifies the breaking of a natural or social balance, and their death is seen as a restoration of that balance.

This moral dimension adds depth to the tragic experience, as the audience not only sympathizes with the hero’s suffering but also recognizes the broader implications of their actions on the world around them.

5. The Audience’s Emotional Response

Bradley believed that Shakespeare’s tragedies evoke a powerful emotional response from the audience, primarily through pity and fear. The audience feels pity for the hero because they are essentially a good person who is brought low by circumstances and their own flaws. Fear arises from the recognition that the same fate could befall anyone, given similar circumstances.

Despite the tragic ending, Bradley argues that Shakespearean tragedies do not leave the audience with a sense of despair. Instead, they offer a sense of catharsis, where the audience experiences a purging of emotions and a deeper understanding of the human condition.

6. The Structure of Shakespearean Tragedy

Bradley identified a general structural pattern in Shakespearean tragedies:

• Exposition: The play introduces the main characters and establishes the situation and conflicts.
• Development: The hero’s flaw becomes apparent, and the forces of conflict begin to intensify.
• Crisis or Turning Point: A critical moment occurs, usually in the middle of the play, where the hero makes a decision or faces a situation that determines the course of the tragedy.
• Falling Action: Following the crisis, events spiral toward the inevitable catastrophe.
• Catastrophe: The final act of the play presents the hero’s downfall, often accompanied by the deaths of other significant characters.

Conclusion

A.C. Bradley’s analysis of Shakespearean tragedy focuses on the complex psychological and moral dimensions of Shakespeare’s characters, particularly the tragic hero. He emphasizes the hero’s internal conflict, tragic flaw, and the inevitable downfall that not only affects the individual but also the wider world. Bradley’s approach offers a profound understanding of the human experience, the struggle between fate and free will, and the moral order that governs Shakespeare’s tragic universe.

Bradley’s work remains a cornerstone for anyone studying Shakespeare’s tragedies, offering timeless insights into the nature of tragedy, the tragic hero, and the emotional power these plays hold over their audience.

Read more: A.C. Bradley’s Theory of Shakespearean Tragedy

---

Top 20 short question  on A.C. Bradley’s theory of Shakespearean tragedy

Top. 20 MCQs based on A.C. Bradley’s theory of Shakespearean tragedy